Mistakes and Blame

 
Objective - To promote a discussion of how we blame others and how we perceive the degree of severity of certain actions by different individuals.

Read and discuss the first short story below.
Why do organizations look for someone to blame when things do not go right?
Why do some people overlook greater misdeeds, while focusing in on minor ones?
What kind of climate is introduced into organizations when blame is the goal when mistakes are made?

Read and discuss the second short story.
What was the final goal of this costly mistake?
Are mistakes good for a company? (Failures are compasses that point to learning opportunities. And learning opportunities are the pathways that lead us to success.)

 


Story 1 - A Tale

Once upon a time a plaque was raging among the animals. The lion, considered the king of beasts, decided to hold a trial and find out who among all the animals was responsible for this dreadful plague, because it must be due to some sin that had been committed. Thereupon the animals were summoned to his presence, and when asked about their respective sins, they confessed. It was now the turn of the bear, the wolf, and the tiger. They confessed that they tore asunder, mutilated, and killed animals and humans without mercy. The verdict was "not guilty," and they were exonerated from all blame by the lion, who simply said that what they did was only their duty and function.

At last it was the turn of the lamb to appear before the court. She began to wonder what wrong she done, when suddenly she remembered that on one occasion, because she was very hungry, she saw some straw sticking out of the shepherd's shoe and ate it. That was it, then. The lamb, without any further investigation, was at once condemned, judged, and pronounced guilty. "For her sin," roared the lion, "has this terrible disaster befallen us all."   


Story 2 - IBM

Although IBM has had a number of successes, one of its big failures was the IBM PC Jr., announced in late 1983 (this is the pc that was first introduced with the chiclet style keyboard). This has often been called the "Edsel of computers" due to its design. When it was dropped a few years later due to slow sales, the project manager dropped in on his manager and asked him, "if he should clean out his desk," as he was expecting to be fired. His manager replied, "We just spent several million dollars training you. Why would we want to fire you?"


Notes
From the Dubner Maggid as told by William B. Silverman in Rabbinic Wisdom and Jewish Values.

Created January 1, 1998. Last update - April 8, 2000.
Leadership Training and Development Outline
About
Donald R. Clark - Webmaster
donclark@nwlink.com
http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/leader/blame.html